Page 1 of 1
Image Source Embedded - Click on Image to Go to Source
Posted: November 13th, 2023, 6:13 pm
by AsleepInYorkshire
Please look at the image below. When we use images on TLF we are required to leave a URL address of the site that hosts the image.
The URL for the image is
https://x.com/CarlBovisNature/status/17 ... 69687?s=20If you move your mouse pointer to hover over the image and click on the image it will take you to the source page. Are we good to use this approach please?
Thank you
AiY(D)
Re: Image Source Embedded - Click on Image to Go to Source
Posted: November 13th, 2023, 7:45 pm
by 88V8
AsleepInYorkshire wrote:If you move your mouse pointer to hover over the image and click on the image it will take you to the source page. Are we good to use this approach please?
Personally, yes, although a bare post of <image> as one sometimes sees, does not necessarily tempt.
V8
Re: Image Source Embedded - Click on Image to Go to Source
Posted: November 13th, 2023, 9:29 pm
by csearle
AsleepInYorkshire wrote:Are we good to use this approach please?
Not as the rules stand at the moment.
The rules say...
All embedded images (including data and graphs) in posts must:-
Include an additional link (URL) to a web page where the original may be viewed in context, or (where the image is hosted on either a domain owned or controlled by the poster, or a hosting site account e.g. Imgur, Picasa, Dropbox, OneDrive, Google Drive) be followed by a statement that the poster owns (or is legally permitted to post) the content of the image.
So the question really is: could the rules be amended to remove the requirement to include an additional link.
Chris
Re: Image Source Embedded - Click on Image to Go to Source
Posted: November 13th, 2023, 11:14 pm
by csearle
I have noticed that on the picture of the day thread this rule seems to be universally violated.
I think that if we went through and deleted all the posts there that don't comply we would be very unpopular. There would be almost no posts left!
C.
Re: Image Source Embedded - Click on Image to Go to Source
Posted: November 14th, 2023, 12:15 am
by swill453
csearle wrote:I have noticed that on the picture of the day thread this rule seems to be universally violated.
I think that if we went through and deleted all the posts there that don't comply we would be very unpopular. There would be almost no posts left!
That would be a bit pedantic. Usually it's obvious from the narrative that they are the posters' own images, without a letter-of-the-law statement of ownership after each image.
Sc.
Re: Image Source Embedded - Click on Image to Go to Source
Posted: November 14th, 2023, 8:14 am
by csearle
swill453 wrote:csearle wrote:I have noticed that on the picture of the day thread this rule seems to be universally violated.
I think that if we went through and deleted all the posts there that don't comply we would be very unpopular. There would be almost no posts left!
That would be a bit pedantic. Usually it's obvious from the narrative that they are the posters' own images, without a letter-of-the-law statement of ownership after each image.
Yes that is way I see it too. C.
Re: Image Source Embedded - Click on Image to Go to Source
Posted: November 14th, 2023, 10:02 am
by tjh290633
An additional point is that, if you touch an image on a mobile screen the source is immediately revealed. Whether that link always takes you to the source article or original context is debatable. I suspect that it does not. The image above does take you to the Twitter/X page. Is that universal?
TJH
Re: Image Source Embedded - Click on Image to Go to Source
Posted: November 14th, 2023, 11:00 am
by swill453
tjh290633 wrote:An additional point is that, if you touch an image on a mobile screen the source is immediately revealed. Whether that link always takes you to the source article or original context is debatable. I suspect that it does not. The image above does take you to the Twitter/X page. Is that universal?
No, it's because the OP has combined both an image tag and a URL tag together. Of course it's not obvious just by looking at the rendered post, so I suspect that lack of obviousness is a good enough reason not to endorse the technique.
Scott.
Re: Image Source Embedded - Click on Image to Go to Source
Posted: November 14th, 2023, 11:05 am
by mc2fool
swill453 wrote:tjh290633 wrote:An additional point is that, if you touch an image on a mobile screen the source is immediately revealed. Whether that link always takes you to the source article or original context is debatable. I suspect that it does not. The image above does take you to the Twitter/X page. Is that universal?
No, it's because the OP has combined both an image tag and a URL tag together. Of course it's not obvious just by looking at the rendered post, so I suspect that lack of obviousness is a good enough reason not to endorse the technique.
And just to add to that, the image itself is at
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/F-1N6YmXUAAZ4_W?format=jpg&name=small and AFAIK there is no reliable way of getting to the article/context page from that (a link or reverse image search
may find it, but on a quick one of each it seems not for this case).