Total Return has absolutely nothing to do with practical matters relating to HYPs for which this board has been set up. Please start respecting that and also read our board guidance. Any further posts referring to Total Return may simply be deleted with no comment as the workload involved in moving it to an appropriate board leaving enough context to make the new thread edifying is quite high.
This was a post noting that a share selected as top up was negative on total return for a number of past periods. In the real as opposed to imaginary world of HYP, it's what matters.
Moderator Message:
The above quote was a mod comment from me although you didn't bother with an attribution. That makes this thread a discussion about the moderation, which is not allowed. If you have an issue with a particular moderation decision then you can PM the moderator (in this case me) for an explanation (which I note you have not done). If you are still unhappy with the decision you can take it up with the site owners using the Room 101 board. - Chris
The above quote was a mod comment from me although you didn't bother with an attribution. That makes this thread a discussion about the moderation, which is not allowed. If you have an issue with a particular moderation decision then you can PM the moderator (in this case me) for an explanation (which I note you have not done). If you are still unhappy with the decision you can take it up with the site owners using the Room 101 board. - Chris