Donate to Remove ads

Got a credit card? use our Credit Card & Finance Calculators

Thanks to johnstevens77,Bhoddhisatva,scotia,Anonymous,Cornytiv34, for Donating to support the site

Black hole at the center of Milky Way actually dark matter?

Scientific discovery and discussion
SteMiS
Lemon Quarter
Posts: 2311
Joined: November 5th, 2016, 9:41 pm
Has thanked: 207 times
Been thanked: 592 times

Black hole at the center of Milky Way actually dark matter?

#416867

Postby SteMiS » June 2nd, 2021, 5:17 pm

https://phys.org/news/2021-06-black-hol ... -mass.html

For several years the scientific community has agreed that there is a mass at the center of the Milky Way galaxy and that the mass is a supermassive black hole—it has been named Sagittarius A*....

Back in 2014, astrophysicists were confronted with a problem they could not explain—a gas cloud that had been named G2 moved to a position close enough to Sagittarius A* that it should have been destroyed and pulled in by the black hole. Instead, the gas cloud continued on its way, unharmed.

The researchers in this new effort suggest the reason G2 was able to survive its journey past Sagittarius A*, was because Sagittarius A* is not a black hole—it is a mass of dark matter. To come to this conclusion, they created a simulation of the Milky Way, where Sagittarius A* was replaced by a mass of dark matter and then let it run. In so doing, they found the Milky Way could run pretty much the same way it would if there were a black hole at its center—nearby S-stars would behave the same, for example, as would the rotational curve of the Milky Way's outer halo.

stewamax
Lemon Quarter
Posts: 2417
Joined: November 7th, 2016, 2:40 pm
Has thanked: 83 times
Been thanked: 782 times

Re: Black hole at the center of Milky Way actually dark matter?

#416923

Postby stewamax » June 2nd, 2021, 8:53 pm

Ah well.
They have replaced a Black Hole - a beastie we know at least something about - with Dark Matter that we know almost nothing about!

ursaminortaur
Lemon Half
Posts: 6944
Joined: November 4th, 2016, 3:26 pm
Has thanked: 447 times
Been thanked: 1718 times

Re: Black hole at the center of Milky Way actually dark matter?

#416940

Postby ursaminortaur » June 2nd, 2021, 10:38 pm

stewamax wrote:Ah well.
They have replaced a Black Hole - a beastie we know at least something about - with Dark Matter that we know almost nothing about!


Since dark matter is supposed to react to gravity in the same way as ordinary matter shouldn't the mass of dark matter collapse into a black hole anyway ? To have the same effect on the closest orbiting stars the dark matter would need to have the same mass and radius and hence the same density as the black hole which should surely make it a black hole.

AsleepInYorkshire
Lemon Half
Posts: 7383
Joined: February 7th, 2017, 9:36 pm
Has thanked: 10514 times
Been thanked: 4659 times

Re: Black hole at the center of Milky Way actually dark matter?

#416941

Postby AsleepInYorkshire » June 2nd, 2021, 10:48 pm

ursaminortaur wrote:
stewamax wrote:Ah well.
They have replaced a Black Hole - a beastie we know at least something about - with Dark Matter that we know almost nothing about!


Since dark matter is supposed to react to gravity in the same way as ordinary matter shouldn't the mass of dark matter collapse into a black hole anyway ? To have the same effect on the closest orbiting stars the dark matter would need to have the same mass and radius and hence the same density as the black hole which should surely make it a black hole.

I know zip about this sort of stuff, but find it very interesting.

But as you say it's called Dark Matter for a reason. It's matter.

AiY

9873210
Lemon Slice
Posts: 986
Joined: December 9th, 2016, 6:44 am
Has thanked: 226 times
Been thanked: 296 times

Re: Black hole at the center of Milky Way actually dark matter?

#416964

Postby 9873210 » June 3rd, 2021, 8:15 am

ursaminortaur wrote:
stewamax wrote:Ah well.
They have replaced a Black Hole - a beastie we know at least something about - with Dark Matter that we know almost nothing about!


Since dark matter is supposed to react to gravity in the same way as ordinary matter shouldn't the mass of dark matter collapse into a black hole anyway ? To have the same effect on the closest orbiting stars the dark matter would need to have the same mass and radius and hence the same density as the black hole which should surely make it a black hole.


As ordinary gas collapses it heats up. Eventually a high enough temperature will generate high pressure which would stop the collapse. The gas has to lose energy through radiation before the collapse can continue. There is a limit on how fast an accretion disk can lose energy and so how fast a black hole can grow.

Dark matter does not radiate. It may or may not have other ways to lose the energy that would prevents a black hole from forming.

At least that's one theory, but no one really knows what dark matter is or does.

ursaminortaur
Lemon Half
Posts: 6944
Joined: November 4th, 2016, 3:26 pm
Has thanked: 447 times
Been thanked: 1718 times

Re: Black hole at the center of Milky Way actually dark matter?

#417079

Postby ursaminortaur » June 3rd, 2021, 2:13 pm

9873210 wrote:
ursaminortaur wrote:
stewamax wrote:Ah well.
They have replaced a Black Hole - a beastie we know at least something about - with Dark Matter that we know almost nothing about!


Since dark matter is supposed to react to gravity in the same way as ordinary matter shouldn't the mass of dark matter collapse into a black hole anyway ? To have the same effect on the closest orbiting stars the dark matter would need to have the same mass and radius and hence the same density as the black hole which should surely make it a black hole.


As ordinary gas collapses it heats up. Eventually a high enough temperature will generate high pressure which would stop the collapse. The gas has to lose energy through radiation before the collapse can continue. There is a limit on how fast an accretion disk can lose energy and so how fast a black hole can grow.

Dark matter does not radiate. It may or may not have other ways to lose the energy that would prevents a black hole from forming.

At least that's one theory, but no one really knows what dark matter is or does.


The defining characteristic of a black hole is that its escape velocity Ve = (2GM/r)^0.5 is greater than the speed of light. That depends upon the density (M/r) and, as far as I am aware*, the limits on radius and mass of Sagittarius A* provided by studying closely orbiting stars show that it satifies the criteria for its escape velocity to be greater than the speed of light. Hence even if Sagittarius A* were made of dark matter its density would still be such that it had an escape velocity greater than the speed of light and hence would be a black hole.

Note. It doesn't matter whether the matter inside actually collapses to a singularity or not - we assume with ordinary matter that it does because we don't know of any force which could oppose that collapse but we also don't know that such a force doesn't exist. Hence whether or not dark matter would collapse to a singularity similarly doesn't matter - so long as the mass and radius are enough to make the escape velocity greater than the speed of light it would still be a black hole.

* of course these researchers may have better information about the mass and radius which may indicate that there is some leeway for the escape velocity to be less than the speed of light. However there have been other explanations for why G2 wasn't destroyed in its last pass such as it containing a star rather than being just a gas cloud.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sagittarius_A*#Discovery_of_G2_gas_cloud_on_an_accretion_course

Other astronomers suggested the gas cloud could be hiding a dim star, or a binary star merger product, which would hold it together against the tidal forces of Sgr A*, allowing the ensemble to pass by without any effect.

9873210
Lemon Slice
Posts: 986
Joined: December 9th, 2016, 6:44 am
Has thanked: 226 times
Been thanked: 296 times

Re: Black hole at the center of Milky Way actually dark matter?

#417147

Postby 9873210 » June 3rd, 2021, 7:26 pm

ursaminortaur wrote:
The defining characteristic of a black hole is that its escape velocity Ve = (2GM/r)^0.5 is greater than the speed of light. That depends upon the density (M/r) and, as far as I am aware*, the limits on radius and mass of Sagittarius A* provided by studying closely orbiting stars show that it satifies the criteria for its escape velocity to be greater than the speed of light. Hence even if Sagittarius A* were made of dark matter its density would still be such that it had an escape velocity greater than the speed of light and hence would be a black hole.



I am pretty sure the observational limits are not that tight. To verify the density is high enough for it to be a black hole requires observations very near the event horizon. This would require observing the accretion disk, not nearby stars. To the best of my knowledge we have not resolved this for Sagittarius A*.

AIUI the closest observed stars where many Schwarzschild radii out. S2 is about 1400 Schwarzschild radii at closest approach. The conclusion that it is a black hole is drawn because there is nothing else we know of that could match the observed limits. But Dark Matter is not something we know much about so there is room for the unexpected.

XFool
The full Lemon
Posts: 12636
Joined: November 8th, 2016, 7:21 pm
Been thanked: 2608 times

Re: Black hole at the center of Milky Way actually dark matter?

#417350

Postby XFool » June 4th, 2021, 3:59 pm

ursaminortaur wrote:Since dark matter is supposed to react to gravity in the same way as ordinary matter shouldn't the mass of dark matter collapse into a black hole anyway ? To have the same effect on the closest orbiting stars the dark matter would need to have the same mass and radius and hence the same density as the black hole which should surely make it a black hole.

That's what I was thinking... :?

But do we know if this is true? "dark matter is supposed to react to gravity in the same way as ordinary matter"

We know ordinary matter is affected by gravity from dark matter - that's how it was discovered - but do we know it works the same way the other way around? Or that dark matter is affected by gravity in the same way as ordinary matter? I have not the slightest idea...

XFool
The full Lemon
Posts: 12636
Joined: November 8th, 2016, 7:21 pm
Been thanked: 2608 times

Re: Black hole at the center of Milky Way actually dark matter?

#417354

Postby XFool » June 4th, 2021, 4:29 pm

Reading the comments to that article is somewhat depressing, IMO.

cantdrive85
Jun 03, 2021
Black hole matter? Black holes matter! Dark holes matter! Dark hole matter?

It's all faerie tales and lies just as with the Marxist BLM.


But then, going back to the 2014 article where the unexpected result was first reported, it is no less depressing to see in the comments the usual list of self-appointed 'experts' lining up to take pot-shots. Whatever for? :

https://phys.org/news/2014-07-explanation-lack-gas-cloud-interaction.html

'Culture Wars'? - "Ain't nobody getting out of here alive..."

ursaminortaur
Lemon Half
Posts: 6944
Joined: November 4th, 2016, 3:26 pm
Has thanked: 447 times
Been thanked: 1718 times

Re: Black hole at the center of Milky Way actually dark matter?

#417365

Postby ursaminortaur » June 4th, 2021, 5:10 pm

XFool wrote:
ursaminortaur wrote:Since dark matter is supposed to react to gravity in the same way as ordinary matter shouldn't the mass of dark matter collapse into a black hole anyway ? To have the same effect on the closest orbiting stars the dark matter would need to have the same mass and radius and hence the same density as the black hole which should surely make it a black hole.

That's what I was thinking... :?

But do we know if this is true? "dark matter is supposed to react to gravity in the same way as ordinary matter"

We know ordinary matter is affected by gravity from dark matter - that's how it was discovered - but do we know it works the same way the other way around? Or that dark matter is affected by gravity in the same way as ordinary matter? I have not the slightest idea...


Our best theory of gravity is General Relativity which just makes gravity into a pseudo force caused by the curving of space-time by mass.
Hence, as long as dark matter, is just made up of some sort of particles which have mass then they should both curve space in the same way as ordinary matter particles with mass and also react to that curvature in the same way as ordinary matter particles ie both normal and dark matter should create gravitional attraction and should react to that attraction in the same way.

(Of course, we know that General Relativity is not a complete theory of everything so that picture of mass curving space-time may be just approximately right in a similar way to Newton's theory of gravity being approximately correct. Thus we can't be 100% sure that dark matter reacts to gravity in the same way as normal matter but that is what our best theory says.)

GrahamPlatt
Lemon Quarter
Posts: 2059
Joined: November 4th, 2016, 9:40 am
Has thanked: 1032 times
Been thanked: 824 times

Re: Black hole at the center of Milky Way actually dark matter?

#417367

Postby GrahamPlatt » June 4th, 2021, 5:21 pm

Just to throw another bit of information into the mix for those that might understand more than me about the matter;

https://www.theguardian.com/science/202 ... r-einstein

“Scientists are interested in these structures because they suspect that gravity may behave very differently inside them.”

SteMiS
Lemon Quarter
Posts: 2311
Joined: November 5th, 2016, 9:41 pm
Has thanked: 207 times
Been thanked: 592 times

Re: Black hole at the center of Milky Way actually dark matter?

#418891

Postby SteMiS » June 11th, 2021, 5:31 pm

Sorry, bit late back to this one, but since there seems to be some interest in the topic

New study suggests supermassive black holes could form from dark matter

https://phys.org/news/2021-02-supermass ... -dark.html

A new theoretical study has proposed a novel mechanism for the creation of supermassive black holes from dark matter. The international team find that rather than the conventional formation scenarios involving 'normal' matter, supermassive black holes could instead form directly from dark matter in high density regions in the centers of galaxies.

ursaminortaur
Lemon Half
Posts: 6944
Joined: November 4th, 2016, 3:26 pm
Has thanked: 447 times
Been thanked: 1718 times

Re: Black hole at the center of Milky Way actually dark matter?

#419464

Postby ursaminortaur » June 14th, 2021, 1:35 pm

SteMiS wrote:Sorry, bit late back to this one, but since there seems to be some interest in the topic

New study suggests supermassive black holes could form from dark matter

https://phys.org/news/2021-02-supermass ... -dark.html

A new theoretical study has proposed a novel mechanism for the creation of supermassive black holes from dark matter. The international team find that rather than the conventional formation scenarios involving 'normal' matter, supermassive black holes could instead form directly from dark matter in high density regions in the centers of galaxies.


I seem to remember seeing a TV program a few years ago about the problems with how quickly super massive black holes formed in the early universe which included direct collapse of dark matter into black holes as one suggested solution. The other solution suggested was dark stars - stars made from a mixture of normal hydrogen and dark matter which were much larger than normal since they were powered by dark matter annihilation.

https://astronomy.com/magazine/2018/09/dark-stars-come-into-the-light

ayshfm1
Lemon Slice
Posts: 290
Joined: November 5th, 2016, 9:43 am
Has thanked: 1 time
Been thanked: 154 times

Re: Black hole at the center of Milky Way actually dark matter?

#420197

Postby ayshfm1 » June 17th, 2021, 2:48 pm

Someone mentioned Dark Matter being 'discovered' surely inferred?

As far as I'm aware despite a huge amount of effort expended no one has proven it's existence. It along with Dark Energy remain little more that number put into calculations that then allow those calculation to model what is observed.

GrahamPlatt
Lemon Quarter
Posts: 2059
Joined: November 4th, 2016, 9:40 am
Has thanked: 1032 times
Been thanked: 824 times

Re: Black hole at the center of Milky Way actually dark matter?

#420207

Postby GrahamPlatt » June 17th, 2021, 4:00 pm

Great low budget film, Dark Star.

John Carpenter, 1974

https://youtu.be/ocse-0bBfo8

kiloran
Lemon Quarter
Posts: 4092
Joined: November 4th, 2016, 9:24 am
Has thanked: 3234 times
Been thanked: 2827 times

Re: Black hole at the center of Milky Way actually dark matter?

#420212

Postby kiloran » June 17th, 2021, 4:11 pm

GrahamPlatt wrote:Great low budget film, Dark Star.

John Carpenter, 1974

https://youtu.be/ocse-0bBfo8

And some great music with the same name: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-Xic-CHInek

--kiloran

GrahamPlatt
Lemon Quarter
Posts: 2059
Joined: November 4th, 2016, 9:40 am
Has thanked: 1032 times
Been thanked: 824 times

Re: Black hole at the center of Milky Way actually dark matter?

#420840

Postby GrahamPlatt » June 20th, 2021, 12:49 am

More interesting material on the subject

https://www.scientificamerican.com/arti ... black-hole

In particular this embedded link: “Various astrophysical constraints rule out PBHs as the dark matter if they have either low or high masses” (https://arxiv.org/pdf/2006.02838.pdf).

So what’s at the centre of the Milky Way isn’t a PBH, but may have been seeded by one, dark matter or not.

XFool
The full Lemon
Posts: 12636
Joined: November 8th, 2016, 7:21 pm
Been thanked: 2608 times

Re: Black hole at the center of Milky Way actually dark matter?

#420994

Postby XFool » June 20th, 2021, 6:31 pm

ursaminortaur wrote:I seem to remember seeing a TV program a few years ago about the problems with how quickly super massive black holes formed in the early universe which included direct collapse of dark matter into black holes as one suggested solution. The other solution suggested was dark stars - stars made from a mixture of normal hydrogen and dark matter which were much larger than normal since they were powered by dark matter annihilation.

What would cause the "dark matter annihilation"? Or do we have to envisage anti-dark matter as well?

GrahamPlatt
Lemon Quarter
Posts: 2059
Joined: November 4th, 2016, 9:40 am
Has thanked: 1032 times
Been thanked: 824 times

Re: Black hole at the center of Milky Way actually dark matter?

#420996

Postby GrahamPlatt » June 20th, 2021, 6:37 pm

XFool wrote:
ursaminortaur wrote:I seem to remember seeing a TV program a few years ago about the problems with how quickly super massive black holes formed in the early universe which included direct collapse of dark matter into black holes as one suggested solution. The other solution suggested was dark stars - stars made from a mixture of normal hydrogen and dark matter which were much larger than normal since they were powered by dark matter annihilation.

What would cause the "dark matter annihilation"? Or do we have to envisage anti-dark matter as well?


That’d just be matter as we know it, Jim.

XFool
The full Lemon
Posts: 12636
Joined: November 8th, 2016, 7:21 pm
Been thanked: 2608 times

Re: Black hole at the center of Milky Way actually dark matter?

#421001

Postby XFool » June 20th, 2021, 7:11 pm

GrahamPlatt wrote:
XFool wrote:
ursaminortaur wrote:I seem to remember seeing a TV program a few years ago about the problems with how quickly super massive black holes formed in the early universe which included direct collapse of dark matter into black holes as one suggested solution. The other solution suggested was dark stars - stars made from a mixture of normal hydrogen and dark matter which were much larger than normal since they were powered by dark matter annihilation.

What would cause the "dark matter annihilation"? Or do we have to envisage anti-dark matter as well?

That’d just be matter as we know it, Jim.

(Assuming you are not jesting)
Would it, why? AFAIK 'normal' anti-matter is not dark matter, so why should anti-dark matter (if it exists) be ordinary matter? Also, normal anti-matter is - just like ordinary matter - subject to electromagnetic forces. Unlike dark matter - which is why it is dark.


Return to “Science”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 4 guests