Page 1 of 1

How best to assess share portfolio diversity?

Posted: March 13th, 2019, 10:00 am
by Gilgongo
I've got a jumble of investments across a number of vehicles (direct holdings, funds, ITs, bonds etc.) and want to keep an eye on how I'm exposed to certain categories beyond the usual shares, bonds and cash.

When it comes to shares, are there any other useful categorisations other than industry sectors? UK vs international I suppose. Is that it?

G

Re: How best to assess share portfolio diversity?

Posted: March 13th, 2019, 1:27 pm
by SalvorHardin
Gilgongo wrote:I've got a jumble of investments across a number of vehicles (direct holdings, funds, ITs, bonds etc.) and want to keep an eye on how I'm exposed to certain categories beyond the usual shares, bonds and cash.

When it comes to shares, are there any other useful categorisations other than industry sectors? UK vs international I suppose. Is that it?

I use countries rather than UK vs International and split companies into those whose business is mostly domestic and those with mostly international. It's fairly easy, though time consuming, to break down sales and profits for most companies by countries/regions - you just have to go through the annual report to look for the sales data.

Care is needed when it comes to breaking down your investments by sectors. For example, Diageo (multinational distiller, vast majority of business is overseas) and Britvic (soft drinks, about 60% of business is in the UK) are both in the beverages sector yet they have very different exposures. Their subsector designations do point out this difference; Diageo is "Distillers & Vintners" and Britvic is "Soft Drinks".

I suggest being a bit flexible; over the years I've come across quite a few cases where people have been looking for a share which fits a "missing" sector. In doing so they buy something that is very similar to what they already have whilst they've ignored something which would provide much more diversification yet because it doesn't officially fall into that sector's official list of companies they avoid it. Also in some cases the sector classification is dodgy. For example, many businesses in support services more properly belong in construction - they like to be in the support services sector because shares in support service companies generally trade at a higher price-earnings ratio than builders.

I (being lazy) tend to classify a company according to the stock exchange where it is listed. So Manchester United is an "American" share for me because it is listed in New York not London. So on my valuation spreadsheet it sits in the Americans group below Madison Square Garden which is a very American company. But then again most mining companies listed in London are only "British" by virtue of their listing, since many of them have no major operations in the UK.

Re: How best to assess share portfolio diversity?

Posted: March 13th, 2019, 4:46 pm
by Gilgongo
Interesting approach, and good points about sectors being a bit tricky. I might just start with supersectors for that reason.

As to the geographical divide, it does feel like quite a bit of work! I suspect I've got enough of a mix for no one territory (other than UK) to make much of a difference though.

Re: How best to assess share portfolio diversity?

Posted: March 13th, 2019, 4:52 pm
by kempiejon
Morningstar offer an investment overview tool called Xray. http://www.morningstar.co.uk/uk/xray/ov ... fault.aspx It a paid for research, I get mine from my broker but I think a free casual user route is available. It breaks down by geographical region and industry sectors.

Re: How best to assess share portfolio diversity?

Posted: March 13th, 2019, 4:53 pm
by EssDeeAitch
Gilgongo wrote:I've got a jumble of investments across a number of vehicles (direct holdings, funds, ITs, bonds etc.) and want to keep an eye on how I'm exposed to certain categories beyond the usual shares, bonds and cash.

When it comes to shares, are there any other useful categorisations other than industry sectors? UK vs international I suppose. Is that it?

G


Have you run a portfolio X-Ray on your investment platform (if available) or direct through a portfolio on Morningstar? That will give you the basics.